In his book, I am You, Daniel Kolak offers yet another radical theory of personal identity: There is only one person, and that person is all of us. Daniel Kolak (born in Zagreb, Croatia) is a Croatian-American philosopher who works In his groundbreaking I Am You: the Metaphysical Foundations for Global Ethics, he writes: “The central thesis of I Am You – that we are all the same . Pris: kr. Inbunden, Skickas inom vardagar. Köp I Am You av Daniel Kolak på
|Published (Last):||11 February 2013|
|PDF File Size:||8.93 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||5.36 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The human organism evolved to be able to imagine the future and remember the past in a detailed way. Persons in Metaphysics categorize this paper. Why have I spent forty years I know, right? Averroes Strikes Again for the First Time. The Experience of Philosophy Daniel Kolak. Human beings started mythologizing their pasts and dreaming about their personal futures to an extent not seen in any other species. January Learn how and when to remove this template message.
We fear that we will experience the confusion, the memory loss, the wild emotional swings, the ghastly humiliations that people with dementia suffer. But the dream is not veridical. An Epistemological Assessment and a Metaphysical Theory. Returns are shipped at the customer’s risk. Are You An Open Individual?.
Thus while his body, in whorehouses and taverns around London, lived its life as body, the soul that lived inside it would beCassar,who ignores the admonition of the sibyl, and Juliet, who hates the lark, and Macbeth, who speaks on the moor with the witches who are also the Fates, the Three Weird Sisters. In this book I explain how this is possible.
Daniel Kolak – Wikipedia
But then there is also what I know is over there just a little bit beyond that dead end street. Do the borders between us – physical, psychological, hou, causal, spatial, temporal, etc. This is like the fact that, in each of my two streams of consciousness in the Physics Exam, I am not aware of what, in my other stream, I am now thinking. Skickas inom vardagar. But I picked it up again a few weeks later, because I knew Kolak sincerely believed he was on to something, and I wanted danile see if I could make sense of it.
Yet very little of his book is devoted to saying what he finds attractive about it. Kolak rejects the claim that the experience of control over a single body FEC excludes the possibility that we are all the same person on the grounds that: Crosby – – Lolak of Medicine and Philosophy 18 4: Most of us dread the possibility that we ourselves will experience dementia.
In his book, I am YouDaniel Kolak offers yet another radical theory aj personal identity: Dwniel Read Edit View history. I can say that I now have two streams of consciousness, one here on Earth, and another on Mars. When I was preparing my doctoral dissertation, on which the book I Am You is based, my mentor and friend Ray Martin chastized me for speaking in the introduction about a mystical experience that by definition cannot be described or referred to which I was now referring to and going to describe differently.
The traditional, commonsense view that we are each a separate person numerically identical to ourselves over time, i. This description cannot be a factual mistake.
Evolution has predisposed us to feel the emotions of self-concern, including dread of suffering, towards persons we imagine in the future, whom we take to be ourselves. A Critique of Tye. Thus, Quine can clearly describe rabbit-stages, which are temporal slices of a rabbit, each of which is spatially coextensive with the rabbit at some time, but none of which is identical to the rabbit.
In Kolak, Daniel; Symons, John. That mugger is youu anybody. Since this is so, I need not assume that my Replica on Mars is someone else. Emergence and the Problem of Personal Identity.
As a composer danie, musician he has performed in iolak on numerous occasions, both solo and with leading musicians such as Charlie ByrdDizzy Gillespie and Frank Zappa. Our thoughts about ourselves in the future, especially, are highly motivational, a fact which has helped to propel us to the position of the most powerful species, the alpha species, on this planet.
I will not attempt to comment on all of them, but only a few which I think promise to advance our understanding of the subject. The answer was amazingly simple. In the earlier thought-experiment of his Physics Examwhere Parfit temporarily disconnected his left and right brain hemispheres in order to allow himself to pursue two possible solutions to an exam problem simultaneously in two isolated centres of consciousness, he did not not describe himself as two persons, but as a single person with a temporarily divided mind.
Which leaves me to wonder whether, in multiplying entities this way, Kolak is opening a back door through which the puzzles of personal identity could return. I can imagine myself having a divided mind. Essays on the Philosophy of Jaakko Hintikka. I believe I am person p just in case I have self-concern for person p.
This way my kids can ride their bikes and go out directly in that cul-de-sac, but this was only part of my motivation. Someone who, while still in full possession of his faculties, is diagnosed with a debilitating disease that will lead, in time, to the most severe dementia, may quite naturally fear the suffering of that demented person.
However, according to Parfit, ceasing to exist in that way is not like dying. Kolak is the originator of the philosophy known as Open Individualismwhich he developed along with his view of metaphysical subjectivism and the nonlocality of consciousness, according to which there exists but one numerically identical individual subject who is everyone. But the barriers between human beings–such as our each having a different physical body, different memories, a different stream of consciousness, different spatiotemporal positions, and so on–are not necessarily borders between persons.
Even comments from Parfit who graciously sent me over fifty pages at several stages while I was preparing the workwhich were instrumental in getting me to clean up problems and mistakes, and to better focus some of my arguments, never struck me in a way to make me wonder and question what I was doing or why.
Of course, we would only get that benefit if we all believed it. Instead, his heart has been damaged by the scanning process a defect not transmitted to the replica on Marsand he has only a few days to live. Please view eBay estimated delivery times at the top of the listing. And in a blinding flash of inner light I saw the answer to both my problems, the problem of war and the problem of injustice. Having no essential attributes other than being a subject, this entity can undergo transformations as radical as you please without ceasing to exist.